Wednesday, April 23, 2014
KRISHNADEV CALAMUR - Who Are Nepal's Sherpas?
The climbing season on
is still in doubt after last week's disaster on the mountain in which 13 Sherpas
died and another three are missing and presumed dead. As
Mark Memmott notes over at our Two-Way blog, it was the single deadliest
day on the mountain. But just who are Sherpas, and what exactly do they do that
makes them so invaluable to mountaineering? Here are some answers.
Who are the Sherpas? Sherpas are a Nepalese ethnic group numbering around 150,000. They are renowned for their climbing skills and superior strength and endurance at high altitudes. Perhaps the most famous Sherpa was Tenzing Norgay, who in 1953 was one of the first two men — Edmund Hillary was the other — to climb
What do they do? Sherpas act as guides and porters, and do everything from carrying the loads to setting up the camps. They secure climbing routes, fix lines, ferry supplies and guide clients to the top of Everest and other Himalayan peaks.
How much are they paid? Sherpas who lead or assist expeditions to Everest earn about $5,000 during
two-month climbing season, well above the country's $430 annual
per capita household income. But to earn that money, Sherpas make multiple
round trips, exposing them to great risk.
(By contrast, Western guides can make as much as $50,000 during the season.)
How much risk? Grayson Schaffer, a senior editor and writer for Outside magazine,wrote in a piece last year that 174 climbing Sherpas died while working in
mountains (over several decades). He wrote: "A Sherpa working above Base Camp on Everest is nearly
10 times more likely to die than a commercial fisherman — the profession the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention rates as the most dangerous
nonmilitary job in the U.S. — and more than three and a half times as likely to
perish than an infantryman during the first four years of the Iraq war. As a
dice roll for someone paying to reach the summit, the dangers of climbing can
perhaps be rationalized. But as a workplace safety statistic, 1.2 percent
mortality is outrageous. There's no other service industry in the world that so
frequently kills and maims its workers for the benefit of paying clients."
Why is it so dangerous? Climbing Everest is no longer the realm of the individual elite climber; it's a big business worth hundreds of millions of dollars to the country. Expeditions start at about $30,000 and can run as high as $100,000 per person. Permits range in price from $25,000 for an individual climber to $70,000 for a seven-person team. And as Jon Krakauer, the author of Into Thin Air, writes in The New Yorker: "Sherpas aren't provided with nearly as much bottled oxygen, because it is so expensive to buy and to stock on the upper mountain, and they tend to be much better acclimatized than Westerners. Sherpas are almost never given dexamethasone prophylactically, because they don't have personal physicians in their villages who will prescribe the drug on request. And perhaps most significant, Sherpas do all the heavy lifting on Everest, literally and figuratively. The mostly foreign-owned guiding companies assign the most dangerous and physically demanding jobs to their Sherpa staff, thereby mitigating the risk to their Western guides and members, whose backpacks seldom hold much more than a water bottle, a camera, an extra jacket, and lunch."
What's in place to protect them and their families? In his article for Outside, Schaffer notes that
trekking agents are required by law to buy life and rescue insurance for their
porters. Those Sherpas who work above base camp get $4,600 in death coverage
and $575 in medical coverage; low-altitude porters are insured at $3,500,
Schaffer wrote. Additionally, each expedition covers its Sherpas, collectively,
with a minimum of $4,000 in rescue insurance.
But, he told NPR's Audie Cornish, the effect of a fatality or injury has severe implications in the villages. "Well, this is sort of, you know, the unseen tragedy of
Mount Everest, which is the fallout back in the
villages. I mean, these villages in the Khumbu are tiny, 40 or 50 houses. And
in each of these villages there are houses with missing men where widows and
orphans have had their husbands and fathers taken from them by the mountain.
When a Sherpa dies, there's usually an insurance payment. In years past it's
been about $4,000. "Just for this season the government raised the minimum
requirements to about $11,000. But that's still — you're talking about $11,000
that needs to go to replace the income a worker would have for 10 or 20 years.
There's a huge ripple effect that goes unseen by the climbing world."