Bharat Bhushan: New Bharatiya Janata Party's troubled road ahead / Sickular Libtard: Nupurgate and after

By Dilip - Sunday, June 12, 2022

NB: Amidst all the flames of outrage, let me add a small reminder taken from daily life: it is not merely the speaking of factual data that counts, what counts more is the manner of speech, the way in which we speak what we think is the truth. In all religious traditions, there are theories (often called myths) about the Divine, which can be spoken with reverence, with skepticism, or with contempt. Whether it is someone walking on water, flying up to heaven, making the dead come back to life etc; all miracles mean something to the believer; and can teach something to non-believers. But when we humiliate people, especially in a charged atmosphere, we are playing with sentiment. And whereas playing with popular emotions has become the preferred mode of politics all over the world, it is behind the scenes that we need to look; where news has become propaganda and social media has become a blood sport.

The name of the game is as follows: number-crunching + policy lobbying for corporates; and culture wars for the masses

The persistent reliance upon hate-mongering by our rulers is motivated by their love for the Nation (they say), but will only lead to disintegration. Enforced homogeneity will provoke resentment and sabotage of justice will result in despair. For the 'nth' time, I ask those in charge of organs of state to step back, think again and retrace their steps. Your nation-worship is disguised atheism, because the gaze of the Almighty cannot be confined to a speck of dust called Earth, let alone India. And those calling for bloody revenge, whatever their faith, should also retrace their steps. Violence begets violence, it's a never-ending spiral. You are not going to achieve greatness, but will only be presiding over disaster and misery. When you wake up, your power will turn to ashes. DS

Bharat Bhushan: New Bharatiya Janata Party's troubled road ahead

Religious issues, unless stoked, tend to have a short half-life. With appeals from Muslim clergy, the countrywide protests over the insult to the Prophet by a spokesperson of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in all likelihood will die down after some outpouring of anger in the community. But remarkably neither Prime Minister Narendra Modi nor Union Home Minister Amit Shah has said a word about the communal discord sparked by the designated public face of their party.

Junior officers in the Ministry of External Affairs have been left to defend the party and the government, assuaging the anger of Muslim nations. Local police have been belatedly mobilised to register cases for disturbance of social peace. In a bid to distribute the blame, a few outspoken Muslims have also been booked. Immediately, the protests, which led to the death of two teenagers and several people being injured, may benefit the BJP, as they deepen the religious rift in the country. However, unfolding events warn of greater instability in Indian politics.

The main culprit in the insult to the Prophet, Nupur Sharma, is infamous for shrill and uncouth interventions on television. But she is not alone. Other BJP spokespersons are equally choleric, pugnacious, and bellicose. Their offensiveness in TV debates may not be directed by the party’s top leadership, but no one seems to have discouraged it either.

A new BJP seems to be taking shape in which public aggression against political adversaries is not only appreciated but also rewarded. There is a greater acceptance of confrontational politics. Those who hark back to the so-called moderation of BJP’s Atal Bihari Vajpayee, and L K Advani’s tenures, fail to recognise that it was a compulsion forced by the dominant political culture of their time. Nor should their role, especially L K Advani’s, be underestimated in raising the ambient communal temperature of Indian politics. Painting the minority community as fanatic, blaming it for historical ‘wrongs’, flagging its extra-geographical religious loyalty and wanting to ‘Indianise’ them were as much strands of their Hindutva politics then as today. Now they have come to full fruition.

Nupurgate and after: Sickular Libtard

That is why despite the embarrassment Nupur Sharma has caused the government, the BJP has only suspended her pending an inquiry. The BJP must fear that its core constituency could react adversely to her expulsion from the party. Many within it think like her. Their support is not only expressed in social media; there has even been a public protest in Gujarat in her favour. And BJP MP Pragya Thakur has publicly said, “If telling the truth is rebellion, then by that coin, I am also a rebel.”

Thakur herself is a representative of a new and less apologetic BJP; she has described Gandhi’s assassin, Nathuram Godse, as a ‘patriot’. She is also accused of the Malegaon bomb blasts of 2006 which resulted in the death of several Muslim pilgrims. She is the perfect symbol of the aggressive, in-your-face next-generation leadership of the BJP.

Within the party cadres, there is a feeling that the BJP need not be penitent for Sharma stating ‘facts’. Protests by Islamic countries are seen as “over-reaction”. Any action by the party or the government which seems apologetic will make them unhappy. If the party and its government are seen to ‘capitulate’, then questions could be raised about the adequacy of other measures projected by the government as disciplining the minorities. The criminalising of triple-talaq for example or pushing for a Uniform Civil Code despite opposition from the Muslim clergy might simply not cut ice as being sufficiently aggressive.

Perhaps it is the need to prevent offending their “core constituency” which explains the silence of the BJP’s top leadership. That may also be why Iran was persuaded to pull down its version of the meeting between its Foreign Minister Hossein Amir Abdollahian and National Security Advisor Ajit Doval. Apparently, Doval told the visiting dignitary that those who had made the controversial remark against the Prophet “would be taught a lesson”. Perhaps the visible reminder of the NSA’s alleged assurance on official record might have confused the BJP party cadre. Such tensions arising from the disparity between the outlook of the party’s supporters and the face its representatives in government must put on for international acceptability have to be managed by the top leadership.

Despite the government’s best efforts to balance its domestic Hindutva constituency with the need to maintain good relations with the Muslim world, the Gulf countries are likely to be on a short fuse henceforth. A majority of them are autocracies which survive by partnering with the Islamic clergy. They cannot afford instability or a restive public opinion. If public pressure on the rulers of these countries increases, they may not remain as solicitous of India as they are now.

The BJP will find it extremely difficult to calibrate the utterances of its loudmouths so as not to hurt Muslim sentiment. Its electoral compulsions force the BJP to divide the electorate on religious lines and that can rarely be done gently or genially. Psychologically at least, the Islamic countries have been put on the other side of the fence as long as the BJP is in power.

Over and above these processes is the security implication of Nupur Sharma’s hate speech. Warped notions of vengeance and justice from among the ‘faithful’ as well as from within radicalised Hindutva elements will make the BJP’s balancing act much harder.

https://www.business-standard.com/article/opinion/new-bharatiya-janata-party-s-troubled-road-ahead-122061300110_1.html

Sankarshan Thakur: Splintered vision

Bharat Bhushan: Frontier of warfare? Wrong to securitise civil society discourse

The truth about Muhammad and Aisha

P. B. Mehta: With eyes wide open, we’re hurtling into an abyss / In Jahangirpuri, bulldozers leave trail of despair

Manoj Joshi: India will come apart if secular contract is torn / Harish Khare: The Real Import of Satya Pal Malik's Warning About Narendra Modi

Press Release: Commemorating Two Years of the Northeast Delhi Communal Riots

Perfection of Wisdom - the 1,000-year-old Sanskrit Buddhist manuscript

Burma - Preachers of Hate

An Auspicious Day

‘Freedom to criticize religion is a touchstone of free expression’ - Interview with Gilbert Achcar

Shobhit Mahajan: The ties that bind religion, popular culture