Bharat Bhushan: Communal djinn and the vanishing State
NB: It would appear that the ruling dispensation known as the Sangh Parivar wishes communal hatred to become widespread and 'spontaneous'. Contrary to their expectations however, this push towards violently imposed homogeneity is not a step toward national unity but a recipe for disintegration and the end of the Indian Union as a law-governed state. Those officials who are looking the other way while all this goes on, are not only in dereliction of their duty but actively complicit in the ongoing criminal enterprise. DS
The djinn has escaped from the bottle and is rampaging across India as
the hijab row segues into objections against the use of
loudspeakers for azaan (call for prayer) and the cacophony
merges with Ram Navami violence. In Aligarh and Varanasi, chanting of Hanuman
Chalisa outside mosques five times a day competes with prayer timings
for Muslims. Raj Thackeray has threatened to replicate this in Maharashtra.
It seems clear that in the second term of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Hindutva social forces have decided to push ahead with their maximum agenda. Minorities will constantly be kept insecure and their religious and cultural practices will have to conform to the wishes of the majority. Where possible, this agenda is couched in the idiom of constitutionality and law - the hijab issue was posited as one of school uniform, azaan is questioned on grounds of noise pollution norms, etc.
However, extra-legal means are plentifully evident with the planting of saffron flags on mosques or the bid to disturb Muslim prayers by reciting Hanuman Chalisa. It would be erroneous and hasty to link this upsurge to the electoral needs of a particular party. That would suggest it was just a conspiracy of certain individuals and organisations or that the State was using them as its instrument. Such explanations are grossly inadequate.
The agenda of Hindutva
social forces is autonomous of any party’s political needs. The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), although a political
front of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), does not control
and define the activities of the RSS. Nor is the activity of the RSS
coterminous with the BJP’s tenure in power. It would not give up its agenda if
the BJP lost power. The RSS also does not dictate the agenda of the Hindutva
social forces inspired by it, or function as their front organisation. Each
entity creates the environment for the birth of others. As they mutate and
adapt to local issues and conditions, they retain their basic genetic material.
Today no one can prove that the Ram Navami riots or recitation of Hanuman
Chalisa outside mosques was orchestrated by a single conductor.
Who could be these
foot-soldiers of Hindutva forces with time on hand to travel to nearby mosques
to read the Hanuman Chalisa five times a day? They possibly
come from a large population of the unemployed who feel powerless, unimportant,
and have little or no money.
According to the
Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE), the Labour Participation Rate
(LPR) in March 2022 (at 39.5 per cent) was lower than that during the second
wave of Covid in June 2021 (39.6 per cent) and the average LPR for April-June
2021 (40 per cent). Despite the absence of a Covid wave and far less
restrictions on mobility, the CMIE notes: “The labour force shrank by 3.8
million during March 2022 to 448 million. This is the lowest labour force in
eight months since July 2021. Employment shrank by 1.4 million to 396 million
in March 2022 which was the lowest level since June 2021.” This means that
while the working-age population has continued to grow, job opportunities have
not expanded simultaneously and there has been an absolute shrinkage in
employment opportunities.
The youth unemployment
rate is also food for thought. According to a study by Ashoka University and
CMIE, India’s youth labour force (which includes “unemployed but willing to
work and actively looking for employment”) has shrunk by 22 per cent between
January-March 2016 (134 million) and October-December 2021 (104.3 million). It
warned of the impact of low employment generation for youth on social
stability.
According to the
latest Periodic Labour Force Survey for April-June 2021, a quarter of the youth
(15 to 19 years) in 22 states surveyed is unemployed (25.5 per cent). While
youth unemployment was in double digits in the states surveyed, it was
considerably higher in the states where communal incidents had taken place – MP
(34 per cent), UP (24.7 per cent), Rajasthan (35.2 per cent), Chhattisgarh (40
per cent), and Jharkhand (34.2 per cent). Hindutva social forces may well be
tapping into this vast reserve of unemployed youngsters. Success may depend on
a mix of circumstances, especially the stand taken by state governments – for
example, Kerala (with the highest youth unemployment rate at 47 per cent) has
been less communalised than, say, Gujarat (11.6 per cent).
Although there is no
direct evidence that unemployed youth are drawn into furthering the communal
agenda, in recent times they have erupted in job-related agitations for
reservations and inclusion in OBC lists. Astounding numbers of job applications
for even the lowest-paid government jobs and increased suicides among the
unemployed are other indicators of the great strain that this section of the
population is under. The government was taken aback when massive protests by
youth broke out in Bihar and in parts of eastern Uttar
Pradesh in January this year over alleged discrepancies in the Railway
Recruitment Board (Non-Technical Popular Categories) examination, in which over
700,000 candidates were shortlisted for just 35,000 posts!
There could also be
other sections of society that join in the ostensibly religious push to put the
minorities in their place. But communalism increasingly serves another purpose
-- mass distraction, taking attention away from issues of jobs and livelihood
while ostensibly giving a sense of power and meaning to the lives of those
excluded from society’s economic activities. This suits the State, which is
unable to fulfil the employment aspirations of this generation.
In the growing
communal imbroglio, however, the State has inexplicably taken a backseat.
Although the ruling dispensations at the Centre and in some states are also
busy ‘othering’ the minorities, it is difficult to claim that they are
consciously in step with mushrooming popular communal initiatives.
Could they be turning
a blind eye because they cannot control these communal forces? Their response
to these initiatives is to treat them at most as a local law-and-order problem.
Even if the political leadership is opposed to the anarchist methods of
Hindutva’s subalterns, perhaps it is doing nothing for fear of being unable to
control them. What will then remain of its carefully cultivated branding of a
'strong' government?
Asim Ali - Collective surrender The story
of New India is not being written by Narendra Modi alone
Your
silence emboldens hate voices: Faculty, students of IIMs to PM
Society of the Spectacle / 'इमेज' - 'Image': A Poem on Deaths in the Age of
Covid
काशी विश्वनाथ मंदिर के महंत ने मोदी, योगी पर लगाया बड़ा आरोप, सुनकर रह जाएंगे हैरान!
Sunita Viswanath: Why I feel the need to
bring my Hinduism to the streets
Sunita Viswanath - I refuse to cede
Hinduism to those who want to make India a Hindu rashtra
Public Appeal by Hindus for Human Rights,
USA
Bharat Bhushan: Burden of bigotry may break Indian democracy's back
Bharat Bhushan - Incitement to violence:
When will Supreme Court take note?
Bharat Bhushan - Save the Election
Commission: Common electoral roll can wait
Bharat
Bhushan: Frontier of warfare? Wrong to securitise civil society discourse
YANN PHILIPPIN - Sale of French Rafale jet
fighters to India: how a state scandal was buried
