Antifragile: How to Live in a World We Don't Understand by Nassim Nicholas Taleb – review
Nassim Taleb divides the world and all that's in it (people, things, institutions, ways of life) into three categories: the fragile, the robust and the antifragile. You are fragile if you avoid disorder and disruption for fear of the mess they might make of your life: you think you are keeping safe, but really you are making yourself vulnerable to the shock that will tear everything apart. You are robust if you can stand up to shocks without flinching and without changing who you are. But you are antifragile if shocks and disruptions make you stronger and more creative, better able to adapt to each new challenge you face. Taleb thinks we should all try to be antifragile.
Antifragile: by Nassim Nicholas Taleb – reviewed by David Runciman
If the idea is nice and neat, however, the book that houses it is just the opposite. It is a big, baggy, sprawling mess. Taleb seems to have decided not just to explain his idea but also to try to exemplify it. One of his bugbears is the fragility of most of what passes for "knowledge" – especially the kind produced by academics – which he thinks is so hung up on order and completeness that it falls apart at the first breath of disruption. So he has gone for deliberate disorder: Antifragile jumps around from aphorism to anecdote to technical analysis, interspersed with a certain amount of hectoring encouragement to the reader to keep up. The aim, apparently, is to show how much more interesting an argument can be if it resists being pinned down.
There are two problems
with this. First, the book is very hard going. Everything is taken to link to
everything else but nothing is ever followed through. Taleb despises mere
"theorists" but still aspires to produce a theory of everything. So
what we get are lots of personal reminiscences buttressed by the ideas of the
few thinkers he respects, almost all of whom happen to be his friends. The
result is both solipsistic and ultimately dispiriting. Reading this book is the
intellectual equivalent of having to sit patiently while someone shows you
their holiday snaps….
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2012/nov/21/antifragile-how-to-live-nassim-nicholas-taleb-review
Book review: Thomas Piketty's Capital and Ideology
Debt:
The first five thousand years. By DAVID GRAEBER
Noam
Chomsky: Neoliberalism Is Destroying Our Democracy
Sam Kriss: 'Neoliberalism' isn't a
left-wing insult but a monstrous system of inequality
George Monbiot: Ayn Rand - A Manifesto for
Psychopaths
George Monbiot: ‘Try to stop me’ – the mantra of our
leaders who are now ruling with impunity
