Rasheed Kidwai - Nehru praise unlocks IAS rights debate
NB: The 'Sangh Parivar' insists that the RSS is not political and should be allowed to recruit members in the bureaucracy. Now it is hounding an IAS officer for praising Nehru! Read more about the The Non-politics of the RSS In the year 2000 the Gujarat government of Keshubhai Patel, with the support of the Vajpayee government, lifted the ban on RSS recruitment among civil servants. In the ensuing controversy Keshubhai said the RSS was not political (the usual story). This was stoutly resisted and the BJP was forced to withdraw.
Also see
Bhopal, May 29: The transfer of a collector who had
praised Jawaharlal Nehru in a Facebook post has set off a debate in the Madhya
Pradesh bureaucracy whether civil servants have the right to express political
views in public. Some officials appear
willing to support Ajay Gangwar, who has been removed as Badwani collector and
posted as deputy secretary at the state secretariat here.
"Very few dare to
stand with truth and rationale to safeguard the basic values of democracy and
humanity. I salute you, my friend," a Facebook post by Rajesh Bahuguna,
additional commissioner with the commercial tax department, said without naming
Gangwar.
Bahuguna hasn't
contradicted commenters interpreting the post as praise of Gangwar.
The 500,000-member
state government employees' union has, in a statement addressed to chief
minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan, threatened a "strike" if freedom of
expression is curbed. But the state chapter
of the Indian Administrative Service Association isn't ready to take the matter
up unless Gangwar lodges a formal complaint, media reports have said.
Gangwar has deleted
his Facebook account and has been quoted in newspapers as saying he would be
forced to quit government service if harassed.
Gangwar had appeared
to take a jibe at the BJP while saluting Nehru. "Is it his mistake that he
prevented all of us from becoming Hindu Talibani Rashtra in 1947?" his
post said in Hindi last week. "Is it his
mistake that he honoured Sarabhai, Homi Jehangir in place of intellectuals like
Asaram and Ramdev... and set up universities instead of gau shalas and
temples?"
Chief secretary Antony
D'Sa declined comment but sources close to him accused Gangwar of violating
service conduct rules. They said Gangwar's
reference to "Hindu Talibani" amounted to spreading hatred among
communities and his reference to gau shalas mocked the Chouhan
government's Nandishala Yojana, aimed at spreading the cowshed network.
Rule 7 in the handbook
of the All India Service Conduct Rules (1964) forbids civil servants from
making "any public utterance... which has the effect of an adverse
criticism of any current or recent policy or action of the central government
or a state government", among other things.
Although Gangwar's
transfer order does not mention any violation of service rules, the state's
ruling BJP is openly saying he has been punished for expressing political
opinions.
"He has violated
the code of conduct. If we insult the system in the name of freedom of speech,
that is wrong," Vishwas Sarang, an MLA from Bhopal considered close to
Chouhan, said. State culture
secretary Manoj Srivastava, a senior IAS officer and regular Facebook
contributor, said he didn't think that Gangwar had been punished for praising
Nehru.
"But criticising
the government of the day amounts to crossing the Lakshman rekha,"
he said. However, Srivastava,
author of several books on culture and religion, has expressed political
opinions too: by criticising Kanhaiya Kumar and his fellow JNU students who are
facing sedition charges. "We cannot
tolerate anybody raising anti-India slogans," Srivastava said.
Former Uttar Pradesh
police chief Vikram Singh has been quoted as telling the news agency ANI in
Lucknow that the Chouhan government should clarify why it had transferred
Gangwar. "If it's just
because of him praising India's first and longest-serving Prime Minister,
Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru, then it is just a petty issue. His transfer, solely
based on what he has said about Nehruji, is not at all justified," he was
quoted saying.
The Congress has
accused the BJP of "intolerance". A serving IAS officer
who didn't wish to be quoted said: "It's funny and sad that the
government, which wants us to use social media, is curbing freedom of
expression so blatantly that the officer was forced to delete his FB
post." He criticised the IAS
Association's silence. Some serving and former IAS officers said it was time
the Centre formulated a clear social media policy for bureaucrats. Srivastava, though,
said Gangwar should have chosen to express his opinions in more subtle and
ambiguous language.
http://www.telegraphindia.com/1160530/jsp/frontpage/story_88387.jsp#.V0wGbDV97IVAlso see