Bharat Bhushan - Yogi Adityanath and the media: A survival game
Only a week ago, Yogi Adityanath’s Chief Ministership appeared precarious amid speculations that misgovernance in UP may cost him his job. However his recent blitzkrieg of the media suggests that he may have saved his seat. Full front-page newspaper advertisements claim that he has always been “two steps ahead of the pandemic”.
The “Teeka jeet ka” (The jab of victory) media campaign is
expected to have multiple favourable outcomes for Adityanath. It may, at least
he hopes, restore his credibility as a leader who is irreplaceable, in the
run-up to the UP assembly polls. It ensures that media space will be flooded
with exaggerated claims, pushing critical and verifiable reporting to the
margins. More directly, pumping sackfuls of cash into their revenue streams may
win him support at the highest managerial level of media platforms.
The campaign’s leitmotif includes a supplication to the “compassionate leadership” of Prime Minister Narendra Modi. This is not just a reference to the Centre’s recent decision to make vaccines free. It also signals a détente with the party leadership. If there was any putative challenge to Modi’s leadership, it is over.
However, the connivance with Adityanath has serious consequences for the credibility of the media. Among other things it has been complicit in projecting sponsored content as neutral reportage. The UP government paid for a report in Time magazine, in January this year, titled, “Hang in there, better times are ahead”. Prima facie what seemed to be a report by the magazine’s own staff on closer examination was sponsored content labelled, “Content from Uttar Pradesh”.
Worse, this so-called ‘report’ was subsequently projected by
several Indian TV channels and media platforms as Time magazine’s “endorsement”
of Yogi Adityanath’s handling of the pandemic. These stories ran with headlines
such as “Time magazine appreciates UP CM Yogi
Adityanath government’s work” and “Time magazine which had dubbed him
‘hard-core’, now becomes his (Yogi’s) disciple”.
Many full-page advertisements, some appearing in national
newspapers only last week, were camouflaged as ordinary reports and carried
headlines such as “UP fights Corona”, “Yogi govt’s multi-pronged strategy bears
results” and “State’s pandemic control model a hit.”
Propaganda by the UP
government is aimed at burying its dismal response to the second wave
of the pandemic, its broken health infrastructure and the shortage of doctors,
oxygen and critical medicines. Pictures of people unable to cremate their loved
ones and burying them along river banks suggest that Covid death data from the
state may be seriously unreliable. It otherwise defies logic that Delhi with
better medical infrastructure, a population of about 2 crore and 7.3% of it
fully vaccinated would recorded more deaths (24,839) due to Covid-19 than Uttar
Pradesh (21,858) with a population ten times larger and a vaccination rate of
1.7% as of mid-June.
The UP government has learnt to manage the media better now. It was known for harassing journalists and intimidating them with police cases for investigating the Hathras and Balrampur gang rapes of two Dalit women in September last year. Confrontation with reporters also occurred over coverage of rape cases linked to former Union minister Chinmayanand (later acquitted) and former BJP MLA, Kuldeep Sengar (convicted). With just one and half years to go to the assembly polls, the state government has shifted strategy by flooding the media with revenue-generating government ads.
The change was apparent in the fourth anniversary celebrations of Adiyanath’s government. Full-page and jacket ads were bought in newspapers and TV news channels were flooded with ads and “messages” from the Chief Minister. Besides the Chief Minister waxing eloquent about his government’s achievements, they also claimed that crime had been brought down during his term, including a 45% reduction in cases of rape and molestation. This aimed to counter data of the National Crime Records Bureau showing that UP reported the highest number of crimes against women (59,853) in 2019, accounting for 14.7% for all cases in the country, as well as the highest number of crimes against girl-children under the Prevention of Children from Sexual Offences Act and it ranked second in terms of rapes committed. More than a dozen national newspapers ran these front-page ads, and some published op-ed page articles celebrating his government’s achievements with the Chief Minister’s own by-line.
Exchange4media reported that “between December 2020 and
March 2021, upwards of 58,000 minutes of ads from the UP government have been
aired only on news television.” And further, “As per TAM AdEx data,
advertisements by the government of Uttar Pradesh witnessed a 27% growth in
print medium during the period between January 2021 and March 2021 when
compared to the previous three months of 2020. The indexed ad volume growth on
TV and radio were 3% and 8% (respectively) in the same period compared to the
period between October and December 2020.” The growth in UP government’s
ad-spend in March over January this year was 41% on TV, 31% in print and 1% on
radio.
Although a Supreme Court-appointed panel has recommended a
ban on government advertisements that glorify political personalities or the
party in power, especially on the eve of elections, its recommendations are
largely un-implementable. One only needs to look at any government ad (except
classifieds and tenders) to see how the guidelines are flouted. Even though the
Yogi government’s ad-spend has reportedly increased by 50% over the last year
across mediums, nothing much can be done if it increases further in the coming
seven months leading to the assembly elections. The UP Chief Minister would
only be following the example of the Modi government at the Centre.
Another Bharatiya Janata Party Chief Minister, B S Yediyurappa, is following the same media strategy, in the face of rebellion within the state party unit. Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal is also accused of using his government’s publicity budget for advancing his party’s interests and of his leadership. Clearly, governments have discovered that advertisement largesse is a more effective way to incentivise media cooperation than punitive measures such as withholding ads and jailing journalists.
https://www.business-standard.
Bharat Bhushan: It suits the RSS to allow BJP to encourage defections from other parties
Modi says Congress committed 'sin' of
partition // The Non-politics of the RSS
The emperor's masks: 'apolitical' RSS calls the shots in Modi sarkar
Naxalites
should lay down their arms and challenge the ruling class to abide by the
Constitution
The Supreme Court, Gandhi and the RSS
The Broken
Middle - on the 30th anniversary of 1984
Public Health-The Nordic Model
Anne Michel and Simon Piel - Rafale
case: Fresh moves towards a corruption investigation
Amulya Ganguli - End of India’s
“Howdy, Modi” Bonhomie with the USA
Bharat Bhushan: Burden of bigotry
may break Indian democracy's back
Bharat Bhushan - Scania Scandal:
Need to step up to the challenge
YANN
PHILIPPIN - Sale of French Rafale jet fighters to India: how a state scandal
was buried
