Book review: The Woman Who Made Modern Journalism
Citizen Reporters: S. S. McClure, Ida
Tarbell, and the Magazine That Rewrote America
Once upon a time, during a period of great technological innovation but also great economic inequality, journalism was striving to define its role in a fractious democracy. Divisions between conservatives and progressives were stark—and angry—and social anxiety about racial injustice and the rise of women was acute. The behemoth size of some corporations stirred alarm. So did the plight of workers with few protections. At the helm of the government was a president with a bully pulpit, ready to upend things. It was one of those rare moments, in the words of the historian Doris Kearns Goodwin, of “transformation so remarkable that a molt seems to take place, and an altered country begins to emerge.”
BY STEPHANIE GORTON; Reviewed by LIZA MUNDY
Once upon a time, during a period of great technological innovation but also great economic inequality, journalism was striving to define its role in a fractious democracy. Divisions between conservatives and progressives were stark—and angry—and social anxiety about racial injustice and the rise of women was acute. The behemoth size of some corporations stirred alarm. So did the plight of workers with few protections. At the helm of the government was a president with a bully pulpit, ready to upend things. It was one of those rare moments, in the words of the historian Doris Kearns Goodwin, of “transformation so remarkable that a molt seems to take place, and an altered country begins to emerge.”
If that sounds
familiar and ominous, take heart. I’m describing the turn of the 20th century,
a time when those striving journalists were defining the bedrock reporting
principles we now take for granted—developing their field on the fly, and
triumphantly. In the process, they confirmed what a potent force their vocation
could be. To revisit investigative journalism being born and magazines thriving
more than 100 years ago is to be reminded that dizzying change in technology
and the media—the refrain of our digital era—is by no means unique to our
moment. Nor is it the whole story. The standards, methods, and collaborative
ambitions that fueled the 20th-century journalistic upsurge don’t look quaint
at all: They
remain as crucial as ever in the effort to hold power accountable….
