Humility is not a peculiar habit of self-effacement...it is self-less respect for reality, and one of the most difficult and central of all virtues - Iris Murdoch in The Sovereignty of Good (1970) ///
Pain make man think. Thought make man wise. Wisdom make life endurable - Sakini, in The Tea House of the August Moon (John Patrick (1953)
Thursday, July 11, 2013
Is the Hindustan Times running a slander campaign against Ishrat Jehan? Third protest letter to Editor // Request to Home Secretary for protection of Shamima Kauser & others
The Editor 11th July 2013
It appears that Hindustan Times and its Delhi based correspondent, Abhishek Saran, are leaving no stone unturned in tarnishing the reputation of Ishrat Jahan. When they can find no material or factual basis to do so, misleading headlines and insinuations are pressed into service. I have already written two letters to you pointing out the false and baseless headlines being provided in Saran’s stories. It was apparent that the sole purpose of these headlines was to malign Ishrat Jahan’s reputation by concocting and implying a ‘guilt through association’.
This pattern is continuing, despite two letters to you, and despite the fact that Hindustan Times was forced to retract the headline in one case.
Today, on 11th July, again a boxed news item on the front-page story, with a detailed story in the inside pages, mischievously refers to Amjad Ali, one of those killed in the 2004 fake encounter as Ishrat’s ‘friend’. The headline in the short stories column reads, “Ishrat companion had old bullet injury”, and the full story on pg. 10 carries the headline, “Ishrat ‘friend’ got gunshot wound treated in Delhi”. The chargesheet filed before the Gujarat court shows that there was no association of Ishrat Jehan with Amjad Ali, and she was abducted and illegally confined elsewhere by Gujarat police. By repeatedly falsely linking Ishrat Jehan to terrorism, Abhishek Saran’s malicious stories in Hindustan Times are trying to manufacture a public opinion against Ishrat Jahan, and are in fact an incitement to violence against the family of Ishrat Jahan.
The newspaper, and in particular the above named correspondent, will be held responsible if any harm comes to the family of Ishrat Jahan or those involved in the struggle. You are required to promptly publish a clarification retracting the false and misleading claim made by the title of the article and issue a public apology for defaming deceased Ishrat Jehan and causing injury and pain to her family. The retraction and public apology should be given the same prominence and published on the front page, as the false title in Hindustan Times on 11thJuly 2013.
Please note that your newspaper Hindustan Times and correspondent Mr. A Saran are legally liable for the false and malicious reports published repeatedly by Hindustan Times. This is my third letter to you pointing out the false and baseless campaign being conducted by your newspaper, Hindustan Times, against the deceased daughter of my client Shamima Kauser. It is apparent that these baseless and false headlines are being given to mislead the reader amounting to a gross abuse of the freedom of press and to cause irreparable harm not only to Shamima Kauser but to general society as well.
You are also required to publish all my three letters in this regard in Hindustan Times and immediately halt the false and motivated vilification campaign being carried out by you through the repeated publication of baseless, malicious and unsubstantiated articles authored by your correspondent Abhishek Saran. No due diligence is being exercised at any level, by the Editor and/or other senior persons at Hindustan Times, making them all culpable and liable under law.
Please acknowledge the receipt of all my three letters addressed to you, which have been sent via email.
LETTER SENT TO UNION HOME SECRETARY, MR. ANIL GOSWAMI & COPIED TO CBI DIRECTOR (as also released to the Press, will be attached here soon)
Dear Mr. Goswami
Please find attached a letter to draw your immediate attention to the grave threat to the life, liberty and security of Shamima Kauser and her children as well as Rauf Lala and Mohinuddin Ismail Sayed, all residents of Mumbra, Thane.
Shamima Kauser, her children and the above named, have since 2004 sought justice for Ishrat Jehan, who was murdered in a fake encounter in June 2004 by Gujarat police in conspiracy with others.
You are requested to take urgent necessary action for their protection.
You are also requested to give an appointment for early next week to discuss the same.
I hope to hear from you at the earliest.
A copy of this email is marked to Director CBI - Shri Ranjit Sinha and to the CBI-SIT Ishrat Jehan at Gandhinagar investigating the murder of Ishrat Jehan and others.