Posts

Showing posts matching the search for First world war

Pat Barker - Why have we ignored the hard-learned lessons of the first world war?

War does not end on the battlefield. Poems by traumatised children in Syria are a reminder that the horror will haunt them forever The soldier poets of the first world war brought the raw horror of the battlefield into the consciousness of the nation. Siegfried Sassoon (whose diaries have just been  published online ), Wilfred Owen, Isaac Rosenberg and others did not flinch from describing the realities of life and death in that war, the fetid trenches and deaths from gas, bullets and bayonets. Today, reading poems by Syrian children who are living through their own brutal war, I am reminded of that first world war poetry. Their young voices describe the overwhelming sadness at seeing their once-beautiful homeland destroyed, their homes flattened and their families killed. Although they are children, they write with the weary voices of adults who have seen too much. Their poems are a window into the appalling humanitarian tragedy that has befallen Syria’s youngest citizens. ...

Books reviewed (The Economist) : Still in the grip of the Great War

The first world war was the defining event of the 20th century. Thousands of books have been written about every aspect of it. More are on the way The two heavyweights on the causes of the war are Margaret MacMillan with “ The War that Ended Peace : How Europe Abandoned Peace for the First World War ” (out last October) and Christopher Clark with “ The Sleepwalkers : How Europe Went to War in 1914 ” (published a year earlier). Both authors are academics: Ms MacMillan is warden of St Anthony’s, Oxford; Mr Clark professor of modern European history at Cambridge. The former is Canadian, the latter Australian. Both books run to nearly 700 pages, cover much of the same ground and have been critical and sales successes (especially “The Sleepwalkers”, which has sold 300,000 copies in 17 languages, including 160,000 copies in Germany). WITH four months to go before the centenary of the start of the first world war, the bombardment of new books from competing historians is growing heavie...

The first world war: the real lessons of this savage imperial bloodbath

Image
David Cameron wants to turn the first world war into a focus of national pride. That should be resisted every step of the way In the midst of deepening austerity, David Cameron is desperate to play the national card. Any one will do. He's worked the Queen's jubilee and the Olympics for all they're worth. Now the prime minister wants a "truly national commemoration" of the first world war in the runup to 2014 that will "capture our national spirit … like the diamond jubilee".  So £50m has been found to fund a four-year programme of events, visits to the trenches from every school and an ambitious redevelopment of the Imperial War Museum. Ministers have promised there will be no "jingoism", but Cameron says he wants to remember those who "gave their lives for our freedom" and ensure that "the lessons learned live with us for ever." Harry Patch, the last surviving British soldier from the trenches, who died at the age of 1...

Simon Heffer: First World War, the battle of the historians

From almost the opening shot, the Great War has been fought over by historians wishing to interpret and understand what happened and why. Their conflict is not over yet. There is a significant difference between writing the history of a subject some of whose sources are still living and breathing, and that of a subject whose sources are only documentary. In the past decade or two the First World War has undergone a transition from one to the other. A few centenarians can remember soldiers marching through the streets on the way to the front, or home in parades to mark what proved to be a hollow victory. Otherwise, the written word in memorandums, letters, diaries, despatches and memoirs forms the basis of our understanding of the period, together with extensive recordings made of old soldiers, sailors and airmen from the 1950s onwards. That treasure trove of eyewitness accounts – what earlier generations routinely heard while sitting on the knee of their fathers and gran...

Robert Fisk: As we move towards the Great War’s centenary, it’s time to recognise the reality of its horror

Why do we want to commemorate the centenary of the Great War? Because it marked the destruction of the “flower of English manhood”? An odd thought, since it also marked the crushing of the “flower” of French and German manhood. The war’s ultimate tragedy, of course, is that it led – quite directly – to the even more terrible Second World War. In other words, the 1914-1918 war was to no purpose. Its unparalleled suffering led the British and French to believe that they could never fight again; but for the Germans, their very failure to win convinced them they must have another war to prove that the Great War was not fought in vain. Max Hastings has already told us that we were right to go to war in 1914. But that’s not the point. We wanted to go to war, much as we wanted to invade Afghanistan in 2001. Indeed, next year’s appearance of even greater numbers of that grotesque poppy on the lapels of MPs and television presenters – inspired by the equally pro-war poem by John McCrae – ...